HOME


History


NewsoftheIrish


Book Reviews
& Book Forum


Search / Archive
Back to 10/96

Papers


Reference


About


Contact



Celtic fans write - Let us be Irish

(Greg Harkin, The People)

Attempts to strip the Irishness from Celtic football club will only fuel sectarianism in Scotland instead of defusing it, a new book claims. Written by leading supporters of the club, the book claims that flying the Irish tricolour at Parkhead is part of the legitimate tradition for fans.

Celtic Minded - a series of essays by Celtic fans - is the brainchild of Stirling university sports studies lecturer Dr Joseph Bradley. Lisbon Lion Tommy Gemmell, a Protestant, says the singing of traditional Irish songs should be accepted as part of the club's history.

The composer James MacMillan, who caused a storm five years ago when he claimed Scotland was rife with anti-Catholicism, asks if there was a "sexual element" to the anti-Catholic bullying he endured during his 1960s childhood in the Ayrshire town of Cumnock.

"We were the 'feminine' and 'weaker' religion after all," MacMillan writes.

"All that Virgin Mary worship and imagine allowing yourself to be belted by 'Penguins' (the Cumnock word for nuns). And we were the perennial losers from the Battle of the Boyne to the various battles of Ibrox (up to circa 1966)."

The prevailing mentality was that "these 'rogerings' were deserved",, MacMillan says.

In recent times there have been calls for the removal of the Irish tricolour from Parkhead and an end to singing songs like Fields of Anthenry.

Bradley said: "When we see people flying the tricolour or the Union Jack we shouldn't get it out of proportion. Rangers and its supporters also have every right to assert their British identity."

Former Rangers vice-chair Donald Findlay, who quit after being caught on video singing The Sash said people had a right to their traditions - as long as they were updated to remove offensive aspects.

"The fact that you stand up for something doesn't mean you are hostile to another man's traditions and viewpoint," he said.

May 23, 2004
________________

This article appeared first in The People on May 16, 2004.

BACK TO TOP


About
Home
History
NewsoftheIrish
Books
Contact